Our rating: 1 out of 5
reviewed by: Charity Bishop
There is something extremely dangerous to mankind, and this is attempting to rationalize bad behavior. Under no circumstance is adultery acceptable; yet movies like The Forsyte Saga encourage viewers to believe it may be right in the proper circumstances. Full of secular worldview and immoral characters, this otherwise glowing period drama attempts to console our ruffled moral feathers by asking us to believe love is an uncontrollable urge rather than a conscious choice. The series focuses on the lives of several branches of the Forsyte family, wealthy upper-crust English aristocrats who "own half of London."
Episode 1 opens in the home of Jolyon Forsyte (Rupert Graves), an enigmatic artist and dreamer. He is strongly attracted to his daughter's French governess Helene, much to the concern of his old-world father and the dismay of his wife. When Mrs. Forsyte demands the woman leave the house, Jolyon and Helene's mutual affection for one another is shown openly and he chooses to leave his wife and daughter and take Helene as his mistress. The resulting scandal ends in his disownment, leaving them to poverty. Nine years later, his proper and businesslike cousin Soames (Damian Lewis) is drawn to Irene (Gina McKee), a mysterious but beautiful woman whose father has recently died, leaving her with barely fifty pounds a year to live on. Convinced she would make him a proper wife, Soames pursues her relentlessly despite her avid rejections of his overtures, but eventually she is forced into marriage out of fear for financial ruin.
Her condition is that he willingly consent to a divorce if the marriage is not a success. Two years later Soames is happy with their lavish lifestyle, but Irene has grown to loathe her husband. "I do not love him," she confesses to his mother when concerns are raised toward separation. "I do not want to love him!" Her unhappiness draws her toward the passionate young architect Philip Bosinney (Ioan Gruffudd), who also happens to be the fiancé of her cousin June. Their affair and the tumulus results on the family name and estates form a turbulent backdrop which trembles in the wake of Soames' wrath, the general unhappiness of all involved, and the eventual dramatic conclusion. The danger in this production is how lavishly portrayed a sinful lifestyle is. There is never any overt regret on the part of Jolyon, who lives with Helene until the death of his wife, on which event they are eagerly married.
One nice consequence of this is that his father seeks to repair their damaged relationship and becomes involved in his grandchildren's' lives; he also shows compassion for Irene when the Forsytes turn their back on her for leaving Soames. However, what little good the miniseries offers is far outweighed by the bad. There is barely a single character worth rooting for. Irene is likable at first, purposefully aloof and jesting; one of her best scenes with Soames is when she intrigues him to abhor society's restraints and dance with her while still in mourning. But later her character fades and she becomes stubborn, selfish, and wretched, choosing to ruin the lives of those around her with flagrant marital affairs. Soames, who I liked early on, takes a sinister twist in the last half by raping his wife. This action leaves us no one left to root for. Even young June attempts to keep her fiancé in her power by offering to "come to his rooms" on Sunday afternoon. He refuses this overture -- so he can spend time with Irene. Amanda Root's character is the only one even remotely likable -- as the young Forsyte married to a gambler. The birth of their first child, the ardent admiration and respect for her husband, and the shock of having bailiffs take personal items to pay for debts endear her to the audience. It's also nice to see her play someone who isn't pathetic for a change.
The worst thing about the adaptation is how gorgeous it is. The lavish London homes, the magnificent gowns, hairstyles, and hats, the stirring English countryside, and beautiful horse-drawn carriages lure the audience into another world they yearn to like for its own merit. The acting is also first rate. Damian Lewis carries off the weight of the film with his interpretation of Soames. Rupert Graves, Corin Redgrave, and Ioan Gruffudd round out the male spectrum, while newcomer Gillian Kearney makes a memorable June. Gina McKee seems slightly restrained as Irene; one wonders why so many men are attracted to her, but fleshes out later in the production. I learned years ago that Masterpiece Theatre can be just as racy as many PG13 films distributed to wide audiences. I was delighted to find restraint in their production of Daniel Deronda, which dealt with excessively heavy topics in a refined and respectable manner. Unfortunately this adaptation falls prey to graphic sexual content.
Dialogue intrudes on several occasions under a "proper" guise, but the innuendo is evident. In the first episode we see Soames making love to his wife; Irene's revulsion is evident. Passionate adulterous kissing is seen many times. A man insists his wife join him in his room; later he enters her room, climbs into bed with her, and forces himself on her. The scene contains brief, shadowed side nudity and heavy breathing. While not overtly graphic, there's no question what's going on -- and we see the horrified reaction of Irene's maid as she passes through the outer corridor. Many times we see Irene and Bosinney tangled up in the sheets, kissing one another, or sleeping in one another's arms. June, in a fit of rage, informs Soames that Irene took precautions to prevent becoming pregnant. Language is present in general mild profanity. Violence also intrudes, not only with Soames struggling with his wife (the next afternoon shows her badly bruised) and attempting to force his way in one night; but in a carriage accident when a main character is brutally trampled by a horse. The grisly image of his dead face lingers on the screen as blood trickles from his lips. His battered body is witnessed later in the morgue. An old man has palpitations of the heart (he has a mild heart attack in one scene) and is shown dead.
What initially bothered me the most about this production was its
implications that marriage, and the natural duties of the wife to her
husband, are revolting. While it is true many women were regarded as
property during the Victorian era, just as many marriages were happy and
equally serving to both parties. This film implies people married for
convenience, were encouraged to discreetly seek comfort if needed
elsewhere, and that sex inside marriage -- which has been God's design
all along -- is revolting. How this is achieved is by running the
extra-marital "true love" of Jolyon and Helene in contrast with the
"cold and unfeeling" marriage of Soames and Irene. Basically what the
film encourages is to seek true love despite the restraints of moral
ethics -- if a marriage isn't "fulfilling," go elsewhere... but
discreetly. That in itself, even aside from sometimes extreme content,
should drive most viewers back to Wives & Daughters.