The Favourite (2018)
This black comedy focuses on a
historical power struggle between two women over who
will control the queen… and her policies.
Lady Sarah (Rachel Weisz) has everything she wants. An
ambitious, diplomatic husband (Mark Gatiss), a court at
her every whim, and total control over the throne. The
emotional, somewhat dimwitted Queen Anne (Olivia Colman)
has total trust in her best friend. Sarah is behind the
war, decides how the court spends its treasury, and
dictating policies while Anne daydreams, suffers from
horrific gout, and mourns her seventeen lost children
through keeping a bunny to represent each one.
But one day, everything changes. Sarah’s ambitious
cousin Abigail (Emma Stone) comes to court—drenched in
crap-laden-mud and hopeful for a position. Sarah tosses
her into the kitchen, but when Abigail learns of the
queen’s pains, a quick trip into the wood for the right
herbs brings her to the queen’s attention. She soon
beguiles Anne. Abigail is everything Sarah is not. She
flatters and gives compliments; she shows genuine
compassion, and is a supportive friend, unlike
the acid-tongued Sarah.
But Sarah has a stronger hold over the queen than
Abigail first envisioned… and it requires desperate,
unladylike actions to wrestle the throne from her sharp
fingernails.
This feels like two movies mashed together. One is
funny, charming, and likable, the other is mean-spirited
and tawdry. I found myself wishing at times the director
had stuck with the former, right before a latter scene
would turn up and make me feel disgusted.
I found a lot of it tasteless. Why would I need to see a
masturbating man on a coach? Yuck. That’s not humor. Why
are the men of the court pelting a fat, naked man with
fruit? Who is he, why is he doing that, and what has it
to do with the plot? And it’s mean-spirited, with no
likable characters except poor Anne, who is a dismal
caricature of the real Queen Anne. The basic premise of
the film is accurate (two women fighting over who
controls the queen) but the details, especially about
how they do it, are false. There is no evidence either
woman had a lesbian relationship with Anne, who was a
devout Protestant and a known “prude.” Sarah in her
letters shows a “disgust of unnatural sexual practices,”
and accused Abigail of doing “perverse things” with the
queen, as a means to discredit her. I think it could
have worked just as well, without turning their
manipulations into cheap sexual tactics.
This movie has countless award nominations. The costuming is excellent. Sandy Powell has done a lot on a tiny budget and going for the full-on outrageous costumes of the time. The acting is tremendous. Colman ranges from pathetic to moving to terrifying in two hours while Weisz and Stone scheme against one another with tremendous glee. But… other things are odd, like the score which has a lovely undertone often ruined by weirdness. And the ending, which is a silent shot that lasts an eternity. I fully understand the message the director was giving us (that for all her schemes, the victor is still a mistreated servant), but the pacing at times felt off (slow). It may rack up some awards, but I have no interest in ever seeing it again.
Sexual Content:
Extreme. Women kiss passionately. One rolls another onto
the bed. A woman enters another woman's room in a sheer nightgown and massages
her legs; it's implied she stimulates the woman with her hand (who reacts with
pleasure). A third woman finds them in bed together, one of them naked to the
waist. A man masturbates on a public coach. References to rape in a joking
manner. A man and a woman scuffle together. When he complains on their wedding
night she is not attending to him, she masturbates him with her hand while
talking about something else. We see a random couple having sex against a tree;
then a woman wakes up in a brothel, with another random couple having sex in the
background; whores flash their butts at a man in the hall. An extended scene has
a naked man being pelted with fruit; his hand covers his privates (barely) until
the end, when he slips and falls. Sexual references, comments, etc. Lots of
cleavage-bearing gowns.
Language:
A dozen f-words. "C*nt" is often used as an insult and
in a sexual manner. General profanities. Uses of "sh*t" and "ass."
Violence:
Slapstick scenes of men and women struggling, men
shoving women around (one pinches Abigail's butt when she leaves the public
coach, causing her to fall into the mud); people shoot at birds, one is hit and
spatters a woman's face with blood. After being poisoned, a person falls from
their horse -- their foot catches in the stirrup, and the animal drags them for
miles. They return with a grotesque scar. Servants are beaten and slapped. A
woman has books thrown at her; she then hits herself repeatedly in the face with
a book to manipulate someone into empathy for her injuries. A woman presses her
foot down hard on a bunny to make it squeal, but it's okay after she pulls up
her foot.
Other:
Historical inaccuracies. Women vomit three times.